This opinion is set out in the document scottish analysis. My family has lived in scotland for years and the greatest victory england could ever have over scotland is a yes vote for independence in 2014. This paper looks at some of the key fiscal questions related to scottish independence, drawing on detailed analysis of household survey data, official data on public spending and revenues, and using a model of the uk and scotlands public finances over the next half a century. The scottish government has today released a white paper detailing its vision for scotland in the event of a yes vote in the upcoming referendum on scottish independence. Scottish independence white paper railways railuk forums. First minister alex salmond will take the formal white paper to the scottish. Scottish independence is the political movement for scotland to become a sovereign state. The scottish governments proposals for early learning and childcare in the event of the snp forming a government following a vote in favour of independence the white paper proposals 1 there are various terms used which differ according to context. This was the basis on which the scottish governments independence white paper scotlands future. Nov 26, 20 a more detailed look at the main points of the scottish governments white paper on independence. Dec 20, 20 understanding how devolution has shaped tobacco and alcohol policies should inform debates ahead of the referendum when the scottish government published its white paper setting out the case for independence, scotlands future,1 public health policy was central to its account of the scottish parliaments achievements. It outlines the various categories of media coverage in common usage and examines a. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us.
Scotlands economic performance and the fiscal implications. Sep 08, 2014 scottish independence could an independent scotland keep the bbc. In 2012 the snp announced that it is opposed to any curbs on student migration17 noting that it believed any such restrictions would negatively affect scotlands economy. Following independence, the white paper promises the continuation of free higher education for scottishdomiciled students studying in scotland. Scottish government white paper on independence december 20 2 happens in scotland should be taken by people in scotland, and not, as. Various contentious international legal questions were examined in. White paper on independence the scottish government. Scotland faces longstanding challenges in health outcomes which are strongly associated with economic and social disadvantage. The free state continued its existence until 1937 when it reformed into. Nov 30, 2009 the scottish government has published its white paper on scotlands constitutional future, paving the way for an independence referendum. Independence will not affect the daytoday management of the nhs in scotland, nor how people access nhs services.
The level of independence of the scottish kingdom was fought over by the scottish kings and by the norman and angevin rulers of england who petitioned the pope and other foreign rulers. Immigration and scottish independence 3 student migration 9. Fiscal challenges and opportunities for an independent. Independence means that scotland should be free to determine its own migration policies. The scottish government says in its white paper that if there were to be a risk to the licence fee at westminster. The snps white paper on independence commits the snp to. First minister alex salmond said scotland must be independent to meet its full economic potential. This chapter examines the scrutiny by the press in scotland and the wider uk, before, during and after the publication of issues related to the proposals presented in the scottish governments independence white paper scotlands future in november 20.
Your guide to an independent scotland argues that independence is the only way to ensure that higher education in scotland remains free of charge to home students scottish government, 20. A more detailed look at the main points of the scottish governments white paper on independence. White paper on independence it also explains the process by which scotland will become independent following a yes vote and how our newly independent scotland will work. Scotlands economic performance and fiscal makeup are key elements in the debate leading up to the forthcoming referendum on independence. Sb 1426 early learning and childcare scottish parliament.
Voices this is what scottish independence could actually look like. A paper from the scottish democratic alliance think tank pdf scotland and the eu common fisheries policy a paper from the scottish democratic alliance think tank pdf how the eu common fisheries policy permanently damaged scotland. That white paper made some specific claims about troop and equipment numbers, but without much in the way of financial calculations to back them up, other than to claim a defence. This guide sets out the gains of independence for scotland whichever party is in government and this governments vision and priorities for action if we are the first government of an independent scotland. For instance, the costs of a university education, and care services for the elderly are free at point of. Twelve of the faults in the scottish governments independence white paper. So the scottish national party has released their white paper on independence. Scotland emerged as an independent polity during the early middle ages, with some historians dating its foundation from the reign of kenneth macalpin in 843. Lord wallace also pointed to fundamental differences between the 1997 devolution white paper and the scottish governments independence white paper.
Scottish parliament only the snp supported this white paper. An independent scottish state would be faced with some difficult choices about how to manage its borders. The scottish governments november 20 white paper scotlands future sets out their proposed timetable for independence to be granted on 24 march 2016, if there is a yes vote in the referendum, as well as the current. With independence, scotland can work towards a fairer society that will address these health inequalities. From kurdistan to texas, scots spur separatists the new. The scottish governments november 20 white paper scotlands future.
Nov 26, 20 following comment taken from the bbc live coverage of the white paper launch. The white paper on scottish independence scotlands future. If scotland were to become independent, the scottish government proposes to introduce the following policies. Scotland and the public health politics of independence the bmj. As its obvious the deal needs to be sweetened a little further. A second independence referendum the institute for government. Most computers will open pdf documents automatically, but you may need adobe reader. In its recent white paper on independence, the current scottish government indicated that an independent scottish state would seek to manage its migration. Asked by chairman iain macwhirter why the scottish government did not go ahead now with the ambitious extension of free childcare outlined in the white paper.
Bbc news snp sets out scottish independence white paper. With independence we can make scotland the fairer and more successful country we all know it should be. Scottish government white paper on independence december 20. Jul 02, 2018 part b of the report, though, is overtly an if we were independent pitch, making it an attempt to replace the white paper of the 2014 campaign. This website and associated newspapers adhere to the independent press standards organisations editors code of practice. This is what scottish independence could actually look. We, the people who live here, have the greatest stake in making scotland a success. These could change under independence, but the inherited tax base and rates, levels of public service and public employment would inevitably be the starting position for a new country. It also explains the process by which scotland will become independent following a yes vote and how our newly independent scotland will work.
Msps asked to endorse independence white paper the courier. The white paper maintains that scotland would not seek membership of the schengen area and reiterates the claim that a scottish government would be able to maintain all of the uks. Independence for shetland and orkney, a new political party, a hard border and a brand new currency are all possibilities. Nov 27, 20 msps will be asked to endorse the scottish governments blueprint for independence in a holyrood debate today. Scottish government white paper on independence university. Nov 26, 20 home library scottish government white paper on independence. Although the main aim of improving childcare is to give children the best possible start in.
The white paper quotes statistics from the organisation for economic cooperation and development that rank the uk 28th most unequal of 34 countries on a measure of overall inequality. Here are the verdicts on the white paper from the comment is free panel, with contributions from ruth davidson. Confusion of a strangely willed kind surrounds the events of 26 january. In addition, the scottish governments white paper on independence issued in november 20 included consideration of different aspects of the future scenario as analysed by the european and external relations committee of the scottish parliament. Higher education, the 2 3 and the referendum on devolution. Maintain free tuition for scottish students studying in scotland but charge fees for students. Scottish independence and defence a look at the numbers. Maintain free tuition for scottish students studying in scotland. Scottish independence in the age of brexit ramapo college. Scottish government white paper on independence by sonny maley on november 26, 20 0. Scotlands once in a generation opportunity channel 4 news. Mar 21, 2017 voices this is what scottish independence could actually look like.
Nov 27, 20 scottish government publishes white paper on independence. However, in terms of understanding scotlands economic pe. It lays out the case for scottish independence and the means through which scotland would become an independent country in personal union with the united kingdom. Here are the verdicts on the white paper from the comment is free. As for the railways im not sure why the scottish government would have much of any say on the matter. The significant decline since then can again be put down to the fall in north sea related gdp. We use cookies to offer you a better experience, personalize content, tailor advertising, provide social media features, and better understand the use of our services. Scotlands future is a government white paper published on 26 november 20 by the scottish government under first minister alex salmond. Scottish council of jewish communities in partnership with bemis empowering scotlands ethnic and cultural minority communities. White paper must own up to the uncertainties of independence. Jul 25, 2014 the white paper states independence would allow an independent scottish government to use the full range of levers to promote good health. Background scotlands first minister alex salmond has been pilloried after unveiling a blueprint for scottish independence that assumes the english would continue to share the uks crown jewels including the pound and bbc programmes. The scottish parliament has protected the nhs from privatisation and restored our tradition of free education.
This is what scottish independence could actually look like. He also outlined a series of other options, including substantial new powers for the scottish parliament. Scottish government publishes white paper on independence. A national conversation your scotland, your voice ii crown2009 isbn9780755981144 thescottishgovernment standrewshouse edinburgh. An emphasis on tackling longstanding health problems through. Nov 26, 20 if it actually came down to negotiating their independence i suspect they might be in a rude awakening and that the independence agreement the scottish people were sold on would not be the one theyd actually get.
If you have a complaint about the editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then please contact the editor here. A central issue here is whether it will be possible to charge students from other parts of the uk to study in scotland, whilst allowing students from the rest of the eu to study for free. This document is available from our website at scotreferendum. A warning for iceland by dr james wilkie, david thomson and associates. Launching the scottish governments blueprint for independence, alex salmond says scotland s future is now in scotland s hands.
1326 327 729 595 505 1051 1023 51 1266 837 224 498 531 1431 349 582 1042 265 1202 663 1007 161 738 1019 1313 1108 893 1234 1264 488 920 933 418